Jeremy is, to all appearances, asleep.

Jeremy: *starts laughing*
Me: What's so funny?
Jeremy: *sad groan*
Me: What?
Jeremy: *sad groan*
Me: What?
Jeremy: I don't remember
Me: So you dreamed of something funny, laughed, woke up, and forgot what it was?
Jeremy: I don't know
Me: Are you asleep right now?
Jeremy: No
Me: Are you asleep right now?
Jeremy: No
Amy: Are you talking to me in your sleep?
Jeremy: No
Amy: What's 4 times 5?
Jeremy: 5
Amy: You are asleep!
Jeremy: 20
Amy: Maybe not...

*pause*

Amy: I love you!
Jeremy: *sad groan*
Amy: Are you upset or something?

No answer. He told me afterwards that he didn't remember anything, so probably had been asleep. It was pretty funny.